The short answer: Often yes. European and Australian courts have held page owners and publishers responsible for comments other people wrote, above all when they knew about unlawful content and left it up. In the United States, Section 230 usually protects you. The practical rule in most places: notice it, decide quickly, keep a record.
This article explains the leading decisions and what page owners usually take from them. It is general information, not legal advice. Liability depends on where you are, who you are and what the comment says, so take real decisions with a lawyer in your jurisdiction.
Why would you be responsible for something you did not write?
Because in several legal systems the person who runs the space where a comment appears is treated as part of its publication. You chose to open comments, you can hide or delete them, and you benefit from the discussion. Platforms like Meta have their own protections as hosting services. Those protections belong to the platform, not automatically to you as the account holder.
What did the European Court of Human Rights decide in Delfi v. Estonia?
In Delfi AS v. Estonia (application no. 64569/09), the Grand Chamber ruled on 16 June 2015 that holding an Estonian news portal liable for reader comments did not breach Article 10 of the Convention. An article about a ferry company drew 185 comments, around 20 of them threatening or hateful toward the company's owner. They stayed up for about six weeks until his lawyers asked for removal, at which point Delfi took them down the same day. Estonian courts awarded the equivalent of 320 euros.
The important detail is that the removal was prompt and the portal was still liable. The Court held that a large commercial portal can be required to take measures to remove clearly unlawful comments without delay after publication, even without notice from the alleged victim or anyone else.
The Court also stressed how narrow the ruling was. Delfi was a large commercial news portal that published roughly 330 articles a day and invited comments, readers could not edit or delete their own comments, and the comments in question were unlawful beyond argument. The judgment was not meant as a license to make every website police everything.
The limits showed up quickly. In Magyar Tartalomszolgáltatók Egyesülete and Index.hu Zrt v. Hungary (2 February 2016), the Court found a violation of Article 10 on similar facts, because the comments were vulgar but not hate speech or incitement, and the sites had a notice and takedown system. In Pihl v. Sweden (inadmissible, decided 7 February 2017 and published 9 March 2017), a small non-profit blog was not liable for an anonymous comment it removed the day after the complaint.
Does a politician's Facebook wall count?
Yes, and with a higher duty. In Sanchez v. France (application no. 45581/15), decided by the Grand Chamber on 15 May 2023, a French politician was convicted over anti-Muslim comments that two other people left on his public Facebook wall during an election period. He posted a note asking commenters to be careful but did not delete the comments or check what they said. He was convicted of incitement to hatred and fined 4,000 euros, reduced to 3,000 euros on appeal, and ordered to pay 1,000 euros in damages to one of the people targeted, jointly with one of the commenters. The Court found no violation of Article 10 by 13 votes to 4.
Three points matter for anyone running a page. Responsibility can be shared between the author, the platform and the account holder. An account holder who knows about clearly unlawful comments and leaves them up cannot claim to be a bystander. And the duty to act reasonably is greater for a politician, who reaches a wider audience.
The Court noted that Sanchez had chosen to keep his wall public, but held he could not be reproached for that choice in itself: it was simply a technical means the platform gave him to reach voters. What counted against him was the local and election-related tension, and his failure to check or remove the comments once he knew of them. If you run campaign accounts, see our guide on moderating comments during an election campaign and the overview for political pages.
Are Australian page owners publishers of comments?
In Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v. Voller [2021] HCA 27, decided on 8 September 2021, the High Court of Australia held 5 to 2 that media companies were publishers of third-party comments on their Facebook pages. The majority relied on the companies facilitating and encouraging those comments. Knowledge of the specific comment was not required to be a publisher.
Two caveats are important. The High Court did not decide that the comments were defamatory or that the companies had no defense; it answered a preliminary question. And Australian parliaments responded: stage two model defamation reforms introduced a new innocent dissemination defense for digital intermediaries, conditional on handling complaints properly, with New South Wales commencing its reforms on 1 July 2024. Adoption has not been uniform across states, so check the law where you are.
How is the United States different?
Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act says that "No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider" (47 U.S.C. 230(c)(1)). The word "user" is why this matters for ordinary page owners, not only platforms. Section 230(c)(2) also protects good faith decisions to restrict material you consider objectionable, so moderating does not forfeit the protection. Section 230 has exceptions, including federal criminal law and intellectual property claims, and it does not travel with you: it is a defense in US courts, not a shield against a judgment in Paris or Sydney.
| Case or rule | Court, year | Who was held responsible | What triggered it | Limit worth knowing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Delfi AS v. Estonia | ECtHR Grand Chamber, 2015 | Large commercial news portal | Clearly unlawful hate speech up for about six weeks before anyone complained | Framed narrowly for big portals that invite comments |
| MTE and Index.hu v. Hungary | ECtHR, 2016 | Nobody; Article 10 violated | Comments were offensive but not hate speech | Notice and takedown counted in the sites' favor |
| Pihl v. Sweden | ECtHR, 2017 (inadmissible) | Nobody; small blog not liable | Comment removed the day after complaint | Size of the page and speed of removal mattered |
| Sanchez v. France | ECtHR Grand Chamber, 2023 | Politician, as the wall's owner | Knew of unlawful comments, did not check or delete them | Higher duty for politicians and public figures |
| Fairfax v. Voller | High Court of Australia, 2021 | Media companies, as publishers | Facilitating and encouraging comments | Defenses not decided; later reforms added one |
| Section 230 | US statute | Usually nobody but the author | Not applicable: providers and users are shielded | Exceptions exist; no effect outside US courts |
What does this mean in practice?
Across the European cases, the same factors keep deciding outcomes: how unlawful the comment was, whether you knew about it, how fast you acted once you knew, how big and how commercial your page is, and whether you had any system at all. None of them require you to pre-screen every comment, and the Strasbourg court has repeatedly warned about the chilling effect of pushing owners toward over-removal. Hiding criticism of your business is not what the law asks for, and it damages trust.
What the cases do ask for is a page that notices problems and responds. Delay is what gets page owners into trouble, and for a large commercial page that clock does not always start at the complaint. Delfi took the comments down the same day it was asked and was still liable, because Strasbourg held that a big portal must remove clearly unlawful hate speech without delay, even with no notice from anyone. Smaller sites with a working notice and takedown system, as in MTE and Pihl, were not held to that standard. A page where nobody is watching the comments at all is the worst position of the three.
A practical checklist for page owners
- Publish a short comment policy and pin it, so the rules are visible before anyone complains.
- Decide who checks comments, and on which days and hours. Write it down.
- Give people an easy way to report a comment to you, by email or DM, and answer it.
- Act promptly on anything that looks unlawful: threats, incitement, slurs, doxxing, clear defamation. Hiding is reversible and keeps the evidence, while deleting does not. See hide vs delete vs restrict vs block for the trade-offs.
- Keep records: what the comment said, when you learned of it, what you did, when. A log is what turns "we act promptly" into something you can show.
- Take screenshots before acting on anything that might end up in a legal complaint.
- Use the free platform controls first. Meta's keyword filters and Moderation Assist, and limiting who can comment on sensitive posts, cost nothing.
- Remember that personal data in comments brings its own rules. See GDPR and comment moderation.
- For high-risk topics, consider limiting or closing comments on that single post rather than running an unmoderated thread overnight.
Who carries the highest duty?
On the current case law, publishers and public figures. News organizations are the Delfi and Voller fact pattern, with posts that reliably attract unlawful comments; the overview for news media pages covers how that workload is usually handled. Politicians are the Sanchez fact pattern. A small local business with twenty comments a week is closer to Pihl, but the basic duty to act on notice still applies.
If the gap is coverage rather than willingness, software can close it. Social Moderator AI reads each new comment against rules you write in plain language, hides or flags what breaks them, and records every action with a written reason in an audit log, which is the record you want if a complaint ever arrives. A tool does not decide what is unlawful for you, and it does not replace legal advice. It does mean a comment posted at 2 a.m. is not still sitting there at 9.
Frequently asked questions
Can I be sued for a comment someone else wrote on my page?
In Europe and Australia, yes, in principle. Delfi, Sanchez and Voller all involved claims against the owner of the page rather than only the comment's author. Whether a claim succeeds depends on the content, your knowledge and your response. In the United States, Section 230 usually bars such claims.
Does deleting a comment admit that it was unlawful?
No. Section 230(c)(2) in the US expressly protects good faith moderation, and the European cases treat removal systems as a point in the page owner's favor. Acting on a complaint is evidence of a working process, not an admission.
Do I have to read every comment before it goes live?
The cases above do not impose general pre-screening, and the European Court has warned against pushing owners toward blanket monitoring. For a small or non-commercial page, a working notice and takedown system plus prompt action is what the Court has accepted. For a large commercial page that invites comments, Delfi goes further: clearly unlawful hate speech may have to come down without delay even if nobody has complained, which in practice means filters or monitoring rather than waiting for reports.
Is turning off comments the safe option?
It removes the risk and most of the value. A quieter middle path is to limit comments on the few posts that attract unlawful replies, keep them open elsewhere, and make sure someone is watching. Closing comments on a public authority's page can also raise its own legal questions in some countries.
Does an audit log actually help?
It helps you answer the question these cases turn on: when did you learn about the comment, and what did you do next. A timestamped record of the comment, the decision and the person or system that made it is far better than reconstructing events from memory months later.